Recovering abandoned carts with a protection offer

How to win back shoppers who left checkout by offering a protection plan: who to follow up, what to offer each group, when to send, what it costs you and how to tell whether it worked.

Works onShopify

A shopper who fills a cart and leaves is close to buying. The usual way to bring them back is money off your products. A protection plan gives you another way: the shopper gets something extra with the order, and the prices of your own products stay as they are. This guide helps you decide who to follow up, what to offer and when. For the screens themselves, see Abandoned Cart Recovery.

What you can do#

You want toDo this
Start recovering cartsAsk for access, then request sending. See Before you start
Give different carts different offersUse Customer segments, available on request, or offer rules
Have every follow-up sent for youSwitch on Automatic follow-ups
Send the emails from Klaviyo or Omnisend, in your own designChoose your tool in Channels and tools
Know what recovery earned and what the discounts costOpen Results

Why a plan works as a recovery offer#

  • Your product prices stay whole. The discount code only ever applies to the protection plan.

  • Each code works once. Every cart gets its own code, so it cannot be shared or reused.

  • The cost is small next to the order. A free plan on a large cart costs you far less than a percentage off the cart.

  • It answers a real hesitation. On a considered purchase, "what if it breaks?" is often part of why the shopper paused.

Treat different carts differently#

One email for every cart either gives too much away or does too little. Sort your carts by how much is at stake.

Kind of cartWhat the shopper needsA sensible follow-up
A large, considered purchaseAnswers and time, more than a discountInformation first: the cart is saved and what the plan covers. A free plan later, if they have not come back
A mid-sized cartA nudgeA reminder, then the plan free
A small accessory cartOnly a reminderOne email with the plan at its normal price and no discount
The shopper had already added a planTo finish what they startedThe plan they chose, free

With customer segments, SureBright builds a starting set like this from your own carts, and you can change any of it. See The starting segments at a glance.

Decide what to give away#

OfferThe shopper pays for the planWhat it costs you
The plan at its normal priceThe full priceNothing. You earn your usual share if they keep it
A percentage offThe reduced priceThat part of the plan price, from your share
The plan freeNothingThe whole plan price. SureBright still invoices its part of the plan as usual

Weigh the cost against the order you get back. Here is an example with made-up figures, for illustration only:

Figure
Cart the shopper left$800
Plan offered freeA $60 plan
SureBright's part of that plan, which you pay$40
What you spend to bring back an $800 order$40

The same $40 on a $50 cart makes no sense. That is why small carts get a reminder without a discount.

A discount sent too soon pays for orders that were going to come back anyway. Lead with information, and keep the free plan for the second message.

Time it to the purchase#

  • Small carts decide quickly. A reminder within a few hours reaches the shopper while they still remember the cart.

  • Large carts take longer. Leave a day before the first message and several days before the offer.

  • Give shoppers a chance to come back by themselves. You can set an earliest send time for every segment.

  • Respect the clock. Set quiet hours and a daily limit under Set the limits.

  • Let the code last long enough. A considered purchase needs a code that is still valid when the shopper is ready.

Avoid sending two emails#

If you already send your own abandoned cart emails, a second one from SureBright will reach the same shopper. Choose one of these:

You wantDo this
Keep your own emails and add the plan offer to themChoose your Klaviyo flow or Omnisend automation as the sender. SureBright prepares the offer and your tool sends it
Let SureBright send themSwitch your own abandoned cart emails off

See Who sends your follow-up emails.

Choose who you contact#

Only carts with an email address can be followed up. Decide whether to email anyone who left an email or only shoppers who agreed to marketing, and add the countries where you need consent. Choose this against your own marketing rules. See Choose who can receive an offer.

Find out whether it worked#

Some shoppers come back whether you email them or not, so counting recovered orders alone flatters the result.

QuestionWhere to look
What did recovery bring back, and what did the discounts cost?Results → Performance: Recovered order value next to Discount you funded. See See what recovery earned and cost
Would those shoppers have come back anyway?A control group: a share of carts that is never contacted. See Measure what your sequence adds
Which offer or timing works better?An A/B test on one segment. See Test two versions of a sequence
Where do shoppers leave?The Overview tab. See See who leaves carts and where

A sensible way to start#

  1. Look before you send

    Once you have the page, browse your own abandoned checkouts. Nothing reaches a shopper until sending is switched on.

  2. Send a few yourself

    With automatic follow-ups off, prepare and send a handful of offers by hand. Send yourself a test email first to read it as a shopper would.

  3. Switch on automatic follow-ups

    Start with a low daily limit and raise it once you are happy with what goes out.

  4. Review after a month

    Read Results, compare what you recovered with the discount you funded, and change one thing.