---
title: "Pre-selected plans and conversion"
description: "What to do when you worry that a pre-selected protection plan is costing you orders, and how to settle the question with a test."
---

**The short answer.** A pre-selected plan can raise the share of orders that include protection. Whether it costs you any orders differs from store to store, and the only way to know for yours is to test it.

## You might be asking

- A plan is added automatically and I think conversions are dropping. Can you turn it off?
- Should the default be the cheapest plan, the longest plan, or nothing?
- Customers say they did not mean to buy the plan.

## What you need to know

**Opinions about defaults are usually stronger than the evidence.** When stores have tested a pre-selected plan against no default, the results have not all pointed the same way. Switching the default off because of a hunch gives up protection sales without proving that orders improve.

**There are more than two options.** Besides a pre-selected plan or nothing, you can pre-select a shorter plan, show a **No coverage** choice so declining is one click, or leave nothing selected and rely on the offer at add to cart.

**Shoppers must always be able to see and remove the plan.** A clear price, a visible plan line in the cart and an easy way to remove it prevent most "I did not mean to buy this" complaints.

## What to do

| Situation | Do this |
| --- | --- |
| You want to know the real effect | Run two versions side by side. On Shopify, copy your live design, change only the default and click **Test against live**. See [Default plan selection](/merchant-portal/default-plan-selection). |
| You do not have Studio | Ask your SureBright contact to set up the test or to change the default for you. |
| Customers say the plan was added without them noticing | Check your cart shows the plan line and its price clearly, and consider showing the **No coverage** choice. |
| You decide against a default | Keep the offer visible on the product page and in the cart so shoppers can still choose it. |

## Get ahead of it

Decide your default at launch on purpose, write down why, and plan one test in your first weeks. A result from your own shoppers ends the debate.

## Related

- [Default plan selection](/merchant-portal/default-plan-selection)
- [Design tests](/merchant-portal/design-tests)
- [Reading your attach rate](/learn/attach-rate)
